Chapter 10 - The Voice of a Dead ManThe flash drive contained audio.
Not stolen recordings.
Robert Donovan had recorded himself.
Twenty-three files.
Most were short.
Dates from the final year of his life.
Claire listened with attorneys present.
Her father’s voice filled the room.
Older than she remembered.
Tired.
“I am recording this because memory becomes negotiable when money is involved.”
Claire closed her eyes.
Robert described 2009.
The forged guarantee.
Daniel’s sacrifice.
Harbor 17.
His guilt.
Nothing Patricia had said was false.
Then file thirteen changed everything.
“Daniel has begun treating our old debt as permanent permission.”
Robert sounded angry.
“He believes I owe him the company.”
Claire looked at Patricia.
Her mother stared at the table.
Robert continued.
“I created Harbor 17 as restitution. It was too much legally and not enough morally.”
Another file:
“Patricia wants peace.”
“She always wants peace.”
“But peace purchased by secrecy becomes another debt.”
Claire glanced at Ruth.
Ruth’s face was unreadable.
Then the final recording.
Made eleven days before Robert died.
“I discovered four vendor entities with no legitimate operating purpose.”
Claire stopped breathing.
“Daniel denies personal withdrawals.”
“He is lying.”
Patricia covered her mouth.
“I have not told Claire.”
“I tell myself she is too young.”
“She is twenty-eight.”
“That is not young.”
“It is fear.”
Claire’s eyes filled.
Robert continued.
“If I confront Daniel publicly, 2009 becomes public.”
“I deserve that.”
“Patricia does not.”
“My children do not.”
A pause.
Then:
“But protecting them from truth may only hand them a larger lie later.”
Claire began crying.
The dead were very good at regretting things when they no longer had to live with consequences.
Robert ended:
“If I do not fix this, Claire may have to.”
The recording stopped.
Nobody spoke.
Finally Claire said:
“He knew.”
Patricia nodded.
“He knew before he died.”
“Yes.”
“And still did nothing.”
“He was planning to.”
“He always was.”
Claire stood abruptly.
Ruth followed her into the hallway.
“Claire.”
“Don’t.”
Ruth stopped.
Claire pressed both hands to her face.
“I spent my entire life thinking my father was the honest one.”
Ruth said quietly:
“He may have been trying to become honest.”
“That is not the same thing.”
“No.”
Claire lowered her hands.
“Why do you keep defending him?”
“I’m not.”
“You loved him.”
Ruth’s expression changed.
Claire saw it.
Not friendship.
Something else.
“Oh.”
Ruth looked away.
Claire stared.
“You loved my father.”
“A long time ago.”
“Before my mother?”
“No.”
Claire waited.
Ruth sighed.
“After.”
Claire went still.
“Did you have an affair?”
“No.”
The answer came immediately.
“He never touched me.”
“But?”
“We were emotionally closer than we should have been for a period of time.”
Claire felt exhausted beyond anger.
“Did Mom know?”
“Yes.”
Of course she did.
Another family secret everyone had carried except Claire.
“Is that why she hates you?”
“She does not hate me.”
“She canceled her daughter’s reception and your first thought is semantics.”
Ruth almost smiled.
Then became serious.
“Patricia had reason not to trust me.”
“Did Dad leave you the letter because he trusted you more than her?”
Ruth took a long time to answer.
“He left it with me because he believed Patricia would destroy it.”
Claire looked back toward the room where her mother sat beneath the voice of her dead husband.
“Would she have?”
Ruth said:
“Three years ago?”
A pause.
“Yes.”
That night Claire stayed alone.
No Ethan.
No mother.
No grandmother-in-law.
She opened the wedding ring box.
The ring sat inside.
She thought about Robert saying:
Protecting them from truth may only hand them a larger lie later.
Then her phone buzzed.
A message from Daniel.
One sentence.
YOUR FATHER DIDN’T DIE BEFORE HE COULD FIX IT.
May you like
HE FIXED IT.
ASK RUTH WHAT HE GAVE HER.
Related Stories
